Stingrays are now not the silent residents of the ocean scientists as soon as thought them to be. Caught on digicam, two completely different stingray species have been found making bizarre clicking sounds in a fortunate discovery that has delighted marine ecologists – but additionally left them stumped.  


“That we solely simply realized that these generally encountered stingrays are making sounds demonstrates, as soon as once more, how little we all know concerning the oceans,” says marine ecologist Lachlan Fetterplace of the Swedish College of Agricultural Sciences, who led the examine.

Practically 990 species of bony fish are identified to make sounds. However elasmobranchs – a gaggle of cartilaginous fish that features rays, sharks, and sawfish – had been all the time considered the stealthy, silent sort.

Not so, it appears. Says Fetterplace: “We now have a number of recordings and observations of two species of stingrays making sounds within the wild”, thanks to a couple avid naturalists.

Two mangrove whiprays (Urogymnus granulatus) and one cowtail stingray (Pastinachus ater) had been noticed by divers who captured them making bizarre sounds, which seemingly function a warning or protection sign, Fetterplace says.

Not like haunting whale songs that journey far throughout the oceans, or bewitching fowl songs that filter by way of forests, the wild stingrays in these movies make quick, sharp, hollow-sounding clicks that sound extra like a percussion instrument than a marine animal.

As you may see beneath, the 2 species produce clicks of barely completely different pitch as they glide by way of the water, an setting that usually sounds muted to human ears however is definitely filled with noisy creatures making a hubbub.

Based mostly on what little is thought concerning the vary of sounds elasmobranchs can hear, Fetterplace and colleagues surmised that the stingrays and their predators can certainly hear these clicking sounds, which fall into the anticipated listening to vary (40–1,500 Hz).


That led them to suggest that stingrays would possibly produce the sounds to keep at bay or startle approaching predators, so the rays could make a speedy getaway.

In all recorded observations – captured utilizing hand-held digital cameras, in 2017 and 2018 close to Indonesia’s Gili Islands and on the Nice Barrier Reef – the rays began making the ‘clicking’ sounds because the observer approached, after which stopped when the diver or ray moved away.

Nevertheless it is also that stingrays’ sounds are a name to arms, to recruit different stingrays when one feels threatened, as one snorkeler noticed.

The query is: How does an animal so flat, whose physique elements are streamlined for an aquatic world, make a sound apart from swoosh?

Researchers assume the rays would possibly make these sounds in methods much like how people snap our fingers or click on our tongues.

“We will not make sure of how the rays are producing the sounds,” says co-author and marine scientist Joni Pini-Fitzsimmons of Macquarie College, “nevertheless it seems to contain fast motion of the top or jaw and spiracles, a gap behind the eyes used for respiration.”

A mangrove whipray resting on a sandy seafloor between mangrove roots. A mangrove whipray at Magnetic Island, Australia. (J. Javier Delgado Esteban)

Stingrays noises have been noticed beforehand, however solely not often. A long time in the past a couple of captive rays had been noticed making ‘crunching’ and ‘rumbling’ sounds when feeding (let’s be sincere, who would not); there have been additionally some anecdotal stories of cowtail stingrays making loud clicking sounds when fleeing from divers in murky waters.

This, nevertheless, appears to be the primary documented proof of the animals actively producing sounds with out being provoked.


Extra analysis is required although to understand the listening to vary of elasmobranchs, “particularly contemplating the restricted variety of examinations on this group to this point,” the researchers write.

“Elasmobranchs are most delicate to low frequency sounds between 40–1,500 Hz, with peak sensitivities between 200–400 Hz, however audiograms have solely been produced for 10 species.”

Contemplating how animals understand the worlds they inhabit in methods we can not actually ever actually fathom, we should not be shocked but regularly marvel at new discoveries that upend what we thought we knew about life on Earth.

The movies seize only some situations of two stingray species making noise, which is likely to be as a result of they solely achieve this very sometimes, when threatened.

Some species of stingrays are solitary creatures.

“They will also be fairly tough to review as a result of they’re typically extremely cell and elusive,” Audrey Looby, a marine group ecologist on the College of Florida who was not concerned within the work, instructed Nationwide Geographic.

Regardless of the challenges, with over 1,200 identified elasmobranch species, researchers assume many extra observations might quickly floor, now that folks know what to pay attention out for.

The analysis was revealed in Ecology.


By 24H

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.