There ought to be no extra revered group of baseball gamers than one of the best catchers of all time. They take a beating behind the plate inning after inning and recreation after recreation whereas managing a workers of a dozen pitchers, and but, we nonetheless anticipate them to supply offensively on prime of that.
That’s why we thought that one of the best catchers in MLB historical past wanted some recognition and their second within the solar.
Greatest catchers of all time
Lately, most discussions about catchers have turn out to be about Posey vs Molina, and for good purpose.
Nevertheless, previous generations have additionally produced among the biggest catchers ever. Whereas it’s powerful to match gamers from completely different generations, the job of catchers stays simply as difficult as they had been years in the past. That being mentioned, it wasn’t simple limiting our record to 10 catchers, however right here is our rating of one of the best catchers of all time.
10. Micky Cochrane
If his profession hadn’t ended early due to an errant pitch that hit him within the head, who is aware of how we might have remembered Micky Cochrane.
However, he was a two-time all-star and a two-time MVP, to not point out a three-time World Sequence champion. Over his 13 seasons within the majors, Cochrane hit .320, which stays one of the best profession common for any catcher, making him worthy of being talked about among the many greatest catchers in MLB historical past.
9. Buster Posey
Even in comparison with catchers of earlier generations, Buster Posey’s accomplishments stand out. His profession ended with 1,500 profession hits and a .302 common. He received the batting title and MVP honors in 2012 and was a seven-time all-star whereas additionally taking part in an integral position within the Giants successful three World Sequence titles throughout his profession.
Posey was undoubtedly one of the best hitting catcher of his era, successful the Silver Slugger 5 instances. He was additionally nice defensively, managing to wrestle the Gold Glove away from Yadier Molina in 2016.
8. Carlton Fisk
He received each Rookie of the 12 months and a Gold Glove in 1972, which was additionally his first of 11 all-star alternatives. On the time of his retirement, Fisk held the all-time data for video games performed and residential runs amongst catchers, though he has since been handed on each lists. However, his 2,356 hits and 376 dwelling runs are nothing to scoff at.
7. Roy Campanella
In one other period, Roy Campanella would have been remembered by historical past much more fondly. He performed simply 10 seasons within the majors, beginning his profession with the Dodgers in 1948, the 12 months after Jackie Robinson broke the colour barrier with the Dodgers.
After all, Campanella made probably the most of these 10 years, successful MVP honors 3 times and being chosen as an all-star eight instances. His profession additionally ended prematurely and instantly as a result of he was paralyzed in a automobile accident.
On the intense aspect, Campanella did sufficient to earn a spot within the Corridor of Fame regardless of his profession being a lot shorter than it ought to have been. Between his 10 seasons with the Dodgers and his years within the Negro Leagues, Campanella is undoubtedly one of many best catchers to ever play the sport.
6. Gary Carter
The late Gary Carter undoubtedly belongs among the many greatest catchers of all time. For those who had been constructing a catcher from scratch, you’d need him to own each trait that Carter had. He knew tips on how to handle a pitching workers, he might discipline his place, he knew tips on how to hit, and he was an unimaginable chief.
Carter discovered his strategy to 11 All-Star Video games whereas successful 5 Silver Sluggers and three Gold Gloves. He additionally received the 1986 World Sequence with the Mets, getting the hit that began the well-known two-out rally in Recreation 6, which means that comeback win doesn’t occur with out Carter.
5. Yadier Molina
Amongst up to date catchers, the Posey vs Molina debate has been an excellent one, though Yadier Molina will get a slight edge. Even earlier than he retires, Molina had finished greater than sufficient to earn a spot as one of many biggest catchers ever.
Exterior of a few the opposite catchers on our record, one must search far and vast to discover a higher defensive catcher. Molina owns 9 Gold Gloves and 4 Platinum Gloves on prime of being a 10-time all-star. He can deal with a pitching workers in addition to anybody and isn’t any slouch on the plate, racking up greater than 2,000 hits throughout a profession that may certainly ship him to Cooperstown someday.
4. Mike Piazza
If we didn’t take protection into consideration, Mike Piazza would probably be on the prime of our record. For what it’s price, he was much better defensively than he obtained credit score for throughout his profession.
Nevertheless, Pizza is greatest remembered as one of the best hitting catcher in baseball historical past.
In his first full season within the majors, he received Rookie of the 12 months, the Silver Slugger Award, and was named an all-star. In reality, it will be his first of 10 straight Silver Sluggers and his first of a dozen all-star alternatives. Plus, his dwelling run when baseball returned to New York after September 11, 2001 will ceaselessly be an iconic picture. For sure, he has a spot in Cooperstown, ending his profession with a .308 common and 427 dwelling runs.
3. Ivan Rodriguez
There are few gamers in baseball historical past who’re extra revered than Pudge. He performed 21 seasons within the huge leagues and at all times appeared to take fewer days off than most catchers. He was again there each day and he was excellent defensively day after day, serving to him earn 13 Gold Gloves, together with a run of 10 straight.
Ivan Rodriguez was additionally a 14-time all-star with many forgetting that he additionally received MVP honors in 1999. His protection at all times earns him accolades, however Rodriguez completed his profession as a .296 hitter with over 2,800 hits and 311 dwelling runs, which is why he additionally received seven Silver Slugger Awards and was undoubtedly one of the best catcher of his era.
2. Yogi Berra
It’s powerful to seek out many huge leaguers who performed 19 seasons, a lot much less did in order a catcher, which is what Yogi Berra did.
Not solely did he play 19 seasons however Berra was additionally named to the All-Star Group 18 instances along with successful MVP honors 3 times, together with back-to-back years in 1954 and 1955.
If successful means something, Berra received 10 World Sequence titles with the Yankees as a participant and three extra as a coach with the Mets and Yankees. Needless to say he did all of that after successful a Purple Coronary heart throughout World Warfare II.
Sadly, he’s solely second on our record of the best catchers ever as a result of the man forward of him was much more particular. However let’s be clear that Berra was the clear alternative for second, far forward of everybody else.
1. Johnny Bench
There ought to be little argument that Johnny Bench is the best catcher in baseball historical past. The man had a profession that even places among the different gamers on our record of the 10 greatest catchers in MLB historical past to disgrace.
Bench was excellent defensively, throwing out runners whereas additionally managing pitching staffs, which is why he received 10 straight Gold Gloves. He might additionally hit, batting .267 in his profession with over 2,000 hits and 389 dwelling runs.
In reality, he held the file for many dwelling runs in a season by a catcher till 2021.
Bench was a 14-time all-star and was twice named MVP. He was additionally the heartbeat of the Reds through the 1970s after they had been the Large Purple Machine, reaching the World Sequence 4 instances and successful world championships in 1975 and 1976. Finally, Bench was inducted into the Corridor of Fame on his first attempt with over 96% of the vote, making it clear that he’s one of the best catcher to ever play the sport.