Subscribe to the Baseball Issues Podcast for bi-weekly evaluation
Seattle Mariners President of Baseball Operations Jerry Dipoto has a repute for being an aggressive, modern dealmaker. Subsequently, it’s solely pure Dipoto’s membership is considered as a contestant within the Juan Soto sweepstakes.

Seattle actually has the participant personnel and monetary sources to dealer a passable deal from the Washington Nationals’ standpoint. However would forfeiting a doubtlessly record-setting package deal of prospects for the two-time Silver Slugger make sense for the Mariners?

The reply depends upon your perspective.

A contingent of Mariners followers need Soto regardless of the price. One other phase of the workforce’s followers is reluctant to dispatch a boatload of expertise for one participant. Each opinions are comprehensible, so let’s contemplate the professionals and cons of buying the 2022 House Run Derby champion.

First, causes Dipoto ought to pursue Soto.

He’s younger

Solely three gamers showing for the Mariners in 2022 had been born after the 23-year-old Soto – outfielders Julio Rodríguez (21) and Jarred Kelenic (22), plus reliever Andrés Muñoz (23). In truth, Soto is one in every of simply 10 gamers, who’re 23-or-younger and have appeared in a minimum of 75 video games this season. Rodríguez is one other.

Not solely that, Soto has already performed in two All-Star video games earlier than turning 24. He’s one in every of seven place gamers to perform the feat because the starting of the 2012 season. You’re most likely aware of them.

A number of All-Star video games by age-23 season (since 2012)
Bryce Harper – 4
Mike Trout – 4
Juan Soto – 2
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. – 2
Cody Bellinger – 2
Francisco Lindor – 2
Corey Seager – 2
Manny Machado – 2

The prospect to acquire a high-caliber performer at such a younger age should be engaging to potential Soto suitors. It’s a possibility that doesn’t occur typically. The latest instance is Miguel Cabrera, traded by the then-Florida Marlins in 2007. The long run Corridor of Famer, who was 24 on the time, was shipped with pitcher Dontrelle Willis to the Detroit Tigers for Dallas TrahernBurke BadenhopFrankie De La CruzCameron MaybinAndrew Miller and Mike Rabelo.

This package deal most likely appeared like a very good haul for Florida on the time.

It wasn’t.

A generational expertise

A 12 months in the past, Mike Petriello of highlighted attention-grabbing similarities between Soto and a younger Ted Williams. Some followers might resist drawing comparisons between a then-22-year-old and one of many best hitters in baseball historical past. Nonetheless, Soto’s early-career productiveness is on par with a few of the recreation’s most recognizable names.

Observe: All statistics are by way of July 25.

Solely 4 hitters with 2,000-plus plate appearances by their age-23 season have recorded a greater OPS+ than Soto. Aside from Washington’s all-star outfielder, everybody listed under is a Corridor of Famer or destined for Cooperstown as soon as they retire.

Highest OPS+ By Age-23 Season*
Ted Williams (190)
Ty Cobb (171)
Mike Trout (169)
Albert Pujols (165)
Juan Soto (158)
Eddie Mathews (157)
Mickey Mantle (156)
Jimmie Foxx (154)
Mel Ott (153)
Rogers Hornsby (150)

*2,000 PA minimal

Soto’s superpower is his elite-level on-base potential. Since debuting in 2018, he has the identical 18.9% stroll charge as Williams did by way of his age-23 marketing campaign. Naturally, Teddy Ballgame is the one hitter with a greater OBP (.481) than Soto’s .427.

Seattle’s offense is meh

Regardless of the addition of Eugenio Suárez, Jesse Winker, and Adam Frazier within the offseason, Seattle’s offense continues to be average-ish or barely worse in a number of classes. Together with baseball’s most necessary stat  – runs scored.

M’s Stats & MLB Rankings Through July 25

Clearly, including a hitter of Soto’s ilk instantly bolsters Seattle’s manufacturing and elongates the lineup. Take into account this: the 2020 NL batting champion’s residence run whole, OBP, SLG, and OPS+ this season are higher than any of Seattle’s regulars.

He’ll be round for a couple of years

Soto isn’t a rental. He has two extra years of arbitration eligibility previous to reaching free company after the 2024 season. Subsequently, the left-handed hitter will probably be obtainable to assist the Mariners make three postseason runs earlier than leaving.

Nobody desires to come back to right here

That is sure to infuriate some Mariners followers, nevertheless it’s true. Whether or not it’s the journey related to being primarily based within the Pacific Northwest or the credibility of the entrance workplace and/or possession, premium free brokers have averted coming to Seattle. There was one notable exception within the final decade-plus and there was a catch.

Robinson Canó did conform to signal with the Mariners. However solely after feeling slighted by his former workforce. The Yankees’ ultimate provide to the a number of All-Star was reportedly seven years and $175 million. Conversely, Seattle’s former possession group permitted former GM Jack Zduriencik to ink the then-31-year-old to a 10-year/$240 million contract. Primarily, the Mariners outbid themselves to land Canó.

In need of overpaying a free agent to a ridiculous stage, a commerce will be the solely manner the Mariners can land somebody with Soto’s credentials.

Okay, we’ve run by way of rationale supporting Dipoto pursuing Soto. Now, let’s contemplate elements fueling angst amongst some Mariners followers. Maybe you received’t agree, however their issues benefit consideration.

{Dollars} and sense

It’s believable the winner of the Soto sweepstakes will probably be required to tackle one of many Nationals’ huge contracts together with parting with prospects. That mentioned, Chelsea Janes of the Washington Publish instructed by way of Twitter that it’s unlikely the workforce would take this method.

Contemplating Janes’ intensive information on how the Nationals franchise operates, her rationale makes full sense to me. You could find her follow-up column on the subject right here.

Having mentioned that, let’s assume the Nationals zig when everybody thought they’d zag. If the workforce insisted on together with a high-cost participant in a Soto deal, one of the best candidate can be beginning pitcher Patrick Corbin, who Janes talked about in her Twitter thread. Some might recommend Stephen Strasburg, who’s at the moment on the IL with a rib damage and isn’t anticipated to pitch once more this 12 months. However this appears even much less seemingly than Corbin being dealt.

Well being points apart, Strasburg is owed roughly $153 million by way of the top of the 2026 season, when he’s 37-years-old. Moreover, the right-hander has full no-trade safety and shares the identical agent as Soto – Scott Boras. It’s inconceivable to me that the Nationals would come with Strasburg in a deal and primarily give Boras some type of affect over Soto’s vacation spot.

As for Corbin, he’s owed roughly $8.2 million for the rest of 2022. The 33-year-old is then set to earn about $59.Eight million for the subsequent two seasons. This features a $10 million deferred fee due in 2025, the 12 months after his contract expires. All informed, Corbin’s price is within the neighborhood of $68 million. This doesn’t sound so dangerous till you take a look at his current file.

Usually, I’m fast to level out ERA isn’t essentially one of the best indicator of pitcher efficiency. However Corbin’s poor ERA aligns with a large number of standard and superior metrics. All recommend the two-time All-Star isn’t the identical pitcher who completed fifth in 2018 NL Cy Younger Award voting with Arizona.

Amongst 101 pitchers going through 500-plus hitters because the starting of the 2021 marketing campaign, Corbin locations within the bottom-10% of a number of old fashioned and nerd classes.

Corbin’s stats and MLB rankings (since 2021)
5.82 ERA (98th)
5.41 FIP (97th)
1.47 WHIP (90th)
.282AVG (92nd)
.345 OBP (89th)
.510 SLG (99th)
.362 wOBA (98th)
.360 xwOBA (100th)
19.Four SO% (82nd)
8.Zero BB% (68th)

Clearly, Corbin has struggled with Washington, significantly over the previous two years. But it surely’s value noting he not often misses a flip within the rotation. Throughout 4 turbulent seasons as a Nationwide, solely two pitchers have made extra begins than his 95 – Aaron Nola (97) and Seattle’s Robbie Ray (96). Gerrit Cole and Jose Berrios have additionally began 95 video games.

Okay, you get the image. Corbin posts, however hasn’t been efficient for fairly a while. Maybe a Soto suitor believes they may also help Corbin recapture the shape he displayed as a Diamondback. Or possibly golf equipment so intent on getting Soto are positive with consuming the southpaw’s wage to get their man. Will the Mariners fall into both or each classes?

Ultimately, this query might not matter as a result of Janes might be right. Making an attempt to dump wage in a deal transport out a generational expertise appears inane. Nonetheless, MLB homeowners have been identified to often make selections counter to one of the best curiosity of the on-field product.

Soto isn’t staying in Seattle

It’s extremely unlikely Soto would stay a Mariner previous the time period of his present contract. Don’t take it personally Seattle followers. The native of the Dominican Republic most likely wouldn’t signal with any workforce earlier than he’s free agent eligible.

Boras is a robust proponent of his purchasers reaching free company to maximise their market worth. This philosophy helps clarify a Ken Rosenthal report that Soto not too long ago turned down a 14-year/$440 million extension provide made by Washington. It’s the explanation Nationals administration is reportedly able to deal him earlier than subsequent week’s deadline.

So many prospects

The prospect price ticket for Soto will probably be steep, maybe historic. The Nationals will seemingly desire a few of these younger gamers have expertise within the majors or be near MLB-ready. Some Seattle followers dread the notion of their favourite prospects or younger major-leaguers depart the group.

Who would possibly the Mariners make obtainable in a Soto commerce proposal?

Onerous to know concerning the big-leaguers. That mentioned, there are not any untouchable prospects in Seattle’s farm system. Names bandied about by varied shops embody a number of gamers with MLB service time – starters Logan Gilbert and George Kirby, reliever Matt Brash, and Kelenic. Farmhands receiving point out are shortstops Noelvi Marte and Edwin Arroyo, catcher Harry Ford, and starters Emerson Hancock, Taylor Dollard, and Bryce Miller.

No matter what number of gamers get moved, there will probably be consternation inside the Mariners fan base. Bear in mind, there’s a contingent frightened the workforce will commerce away the subsequent Adam Jones. It’s actually a chance, however dealing prospects with potential for main leaguers with elite-level credentials is definitely worth the threat.

Suboptimal protection 

For all of the reward Soto receives for his offensive prowess, superior metrics recommend he’s delivered less-than-ideal protection these days. His -Three defensive runs saved (DRS) ranks 12th amongst 16 proper fielders with 400-plus innings on the place this season. For additional context, the Mariners have two gamers with +Three DRS in proper subject in lower than 200 frames – Kelenic and Dylan Moore.

The Baseball Savant metric outs above common (OAA) portrays Soto’s glove work in a good dimmer mild. His -9 OOA ranks final amongst 123 outfielders on the Statcast leaderboard. A current sequence of tweets from Petriello tried to decode Soto’s defensive points utilizing stats and video examples. It’s value trying out.

Not so quick, my buddy

Soto isn’t a speedster. His 26.1 ft/sec dash pace this season is slightly below the MLB-average. Equally, FanGraphs’ base operating metric (BsR), which the positioning makes use of in its WAR computations, ranks him 145th of 155 certified MLB hitters.

Within the grand scheme of issues, Soto’s pace could appear irrelevant to followers wanting the Mariners to amass him. Perhaps it’s. Then once more, he’s solely 23.

What is going to that dash pace appear to be by his late-twenties?

Determination time

Once I got down to write this piece, ambivalence would greatest describe my sentiment relating to a pursuit of Soto. If the Mariners landed him, nice. If the workforce whiffed or handed on the chance to commerce for baseball’s hottest commodity, positive. To a level, these emotions stay unchanged.

Nonetheless, I do imagine the Mariners ought to make the leap and go after Soto. Dipoto might be already doing so.

The Mariners’ struggles to draw elite free brokers might not change within the short-term. Subsequently, getting an distinctive participant like Soto, who might doubtlessly assist the membership attain the postseason thrice is splendidly engaging.

Certain, the value for Soto will probably be steep. Whether or not it contains an exorbitant contract or the Mariners forking over a really vital package deal of prospect fairness, that’s the price of doing enterprise. Particularly when a generational expertise is concerned.

Sure, Soto seemingly walks on the finish of his contract. So what? If his already substandard pace and protection are indicators of what’s to come back, the Mariners received’t have to fret about it. He’s a goner after his age-25 season.

And about these prospects. If buying Soto in some way helps usher in a championship period for the Mariners, the sorrow felt from dropping a couple of common minor-leaguers will probably be swept away by jubilation within the Emerald Metropolis.

Yep, the Mariners buying and selling for Soto is a no brainer.

My Oh My…

The next two tabs change content material under.

Luke Arkins

Luke is a local New Yorker, who grew up as a Mets fan. After the US Navy moved him to the Pacific Northwest in 2009, he determined to make Seattle his residence.
In 2014, Luke joined the Prospect Insider workforce. Throughout baseball season, he can typically be discovered observing the native workforce at T-Cellular Park.
You possibly can observe Luke on Twitter @luke_arkins

Newest posts by Luke Arkins (see all)

By 24H

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.